| Platinum | Banquet Schusters Bakery |
| Gold | The Sacred Bean |
| Silver | Hopscotch Bakery |
| Bronze | Crumbl Cookies - Pueblo |
| Top Pick | Bite Me Cake Company |
| Top Pick | Cakes By Marie |
| Top Pick | Little Bite of Heaven |
| Top Pick | Pretzelmaker |
| Top Pick | Risolletti's |
| Top Pick | Village Inn |