| Platinum | Collette's Catering-Carry Out |
| Gold | Toni & Joe's Pizza |
| Silver | La Forchetta da Massi |
| Bronze | Do Drop Inn |
| Top Pick | Bella Pasta & Chicken |
| Top Pick | East Coast Pizza |
| Top Pick | Gagliano's Italian Market |
| Top Pick | Pasta Cottage |
| Top Pick | The Beer Barrel |