| Platinum | Bella Pasta & Seafood |
| Gold | Toni & Joe's Pizza |
| Silver | Do Drop Inn |
| Bronze | La Tronica's |
| Top Pick | AJ's at Walking Stick |
| Top Pick | Angelo's Pizza Parlor |
| Top Pick | Giodone's Italian Bar & Grill |
| Top Pick | Ianne's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | La Forchetta da Massi |
| Top Pick | Rosario's at the Riverwalk |